How to Enforce Foreign Law in Bangladesh
In an increasingly globalized world, cross-border transactions have become routine, bringing with them a rise in disputes that often culminate in foreign court judgments or decrees. For a country like Bangladesh, which is rapidly integrating into the global economy, the enforcement of foreign judgments is crucial for ensuring that international transactions are reliable and that foreign investors feel secure. This article explores the legal framework governing the enforcement of foreign judgments in Bangladesh, the challenges that arise, and the necessary steps for successful enforcement.
Legal Framework for Enforcing Foreign Judgments
In Bangladesh, the enforcement of foreign judgments is primarily governed by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). The CPC provides the legal foundation for recognizing and executing foreign judgments, ensuring that foreign decrees can be enforced in Bangladesh, provided they meet specific criteria.
Definitions of Foreign Court and Foreign Judgment
The CPC defines key terms that are essential for understanding the enforcement process:
- Foreign Court: According to Section 2(5) of the CPC, a foreign court is any court situated outside the jurisdiction of Bangladesh.
- Foreign Judgment: Section 2(6) of the CPC defines a foreign judgment as the judgment of a foreign court.
These definitions establish the scope of what can be considered a foreign judgment and lay the groundwork for further legal provisions concerning enforcement.
Conditions for Enforcing Foreign Judgments
The enforcement of a foreign judgment in Bangladesh is subject to several conditions and limitations outlined in the CPC. The most relevant provisions are Sections 13, 14, and 44A of the CPC.
Section 13: Exceptions to Conclusiveness
Section 13 of the CPC lays down six exceptions under which a foreign judgment will not be considered conclusive, meaning it cannot be enforced in Bangladesh. These exceptions are:
- Lack of Competent Jurisdiction: The foreign court must have had proper jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties involved. If it did not, the judgment is not enforceable.
- Not on Merits: If the judgment was not given on the merits of the case, it cannot be enforced.
- Against Public Policy: If the judgment violates the public policy of Bangladesh, it will not be recognized.
- Fraud: A judgment obtained by fraud is not enforceable.
- Contradiction of Previous Judgments: If the judgment is in contradiction to a previous judgment by a competent Bangladeshi court, it will not be enforced.
- Violation of Natural Justice: If the foreign court did not follow principles of natural justice, such as giving both parties a fair opportunity to present their case, the judgment is unenforceable.
These exceptions are critical in determining whether a foreign judgment can be enforced in Bangladesh, as they protect the country’s legal system from judgments that are unjust or obtained through improper means.
Section 14: Presumption of Competency
Section 14 of the CPC provides that a foreign court is presumed to be competent, and its judgment is presumed to be on the merits unless proven otherwise. This presumption simplifies the process of enforcing foreign judgments, as the burden of proof lies with the party challenging the judgment.
Section 44A: Execution of Judgments from Reciprocating Territories
Section 44A of the CPC is particularly important for enforcing foreign judgments. It allows for the execution of judgments from courts in reciprocating territories. A reciprocating territory is a country with which Bangladesh has a mutual agreement for the enforcement of judgments. Under Section 44A, a judgment from a court in a reciprocating territory can be executed in Bangladesh as if it were a judgment of a Bangladeshi court, provided it does not fall under any of the exceptions outlined in Section 13.
Process of Enforcing Foreign Judgments
The process for enforcing a foreign judgment in Bangladesh generally follows two routes:
Execution Under Section 44A:
- For judgments from reciprocating territories, the process is relatively straightforward. The judgment holder must file an execution petition in a Bangladeshi court, along with a certified copy of the foreign judgment. The court will then proceed with the execution, treating the foreign judgment as if it were a domestic one.
Filing a Fresh Suit:
- If the foreign judgment comes from a non-reciprocating territory, the judgment holder cannot directly execute the judgment in Bangladesh. Instead, they must file a fresh suit based on the foreign judgment. The court will then adjudicate the case, considering the foreign judgment as evidence. If the court finds in favor of the judgment holder, it will issue a new judgment that can be executed in Bangladesh.
Limitations and Challenges in Enforcement
While the legal framework for enforcing foreign judgments in Bangladesh is well-established, several challenges remain that can hinder the process.
Lack of Comprehensive Legislation
Bangladesh currently lacks a comprehensive law specifically dedicated to the enforcement of foreign judgments. While the CPC provides the basic framework, it is not exhaustive and does not address all the nuances of cross-border legal disputes. This gap in the legal framework can lead to inconsistencies and uncertainties in the enforcement process.
Reciprocity Issues
The concept of reciprocity is crucial for the enforcement of foreign judgments under Section 44A of the CPC. However, Bangladesh does not have a publicly available, updated list of reciprocating territories. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for foreign judgment holders to determine whether their judgments can be enforced directly in Bangladesh.
Practical Difficulties
Enforcing foreign judgments in Bangladesh can be a time-consuming and bureaucratic process. The legal system is often plagued by delays, red tape, and corruption, all of which can significantly slow down the enforcement process. Additionally, the absence of specialized courts or tribunals for handling foreign judgment enforcement further complicates the process.
The Need for Legal Reforms
To address these challenges and streamline the process of enforcing foreign judgments, Bangladesh should consider implementing several key reforms.
Comprehensive Legislation
One of the most critical steps Bangladesh can take is to enact comprehensive legislation specifically dealing with the enforcement of foreign judgments. Such legislation should clarify the procedures, address any gaps in the current legal framework, and ensure consistency with international standards. The United Kingdom’s Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933 could serve as a model for such legislation.
Specialized Courts or Tribunals
Establishing specialized courts or tribunals to handle cases related to the enforcement of foreign judgments would improve efficiency and reduce delays. These courts could be staffed with judges and legal experts who have experience in international law and cross-border disputes, ensuring that cases are handled with the necessary expertise.
Updated List of Reciprocating Territories
To facilitate the enforcement process, Bangladesh should maintain and make publicly available an updated list of reciprocating territories. This would provide clarity to foreign judgment holders and ensure that the enforcement process under Section 44A of the CPC is transparent and predictable.
International Cooperation
Enhancing international cooperation is another crucial aspect of improving the enforcement of foreign judgments in Bangladesh. By entering into more reciprocal enforcement agreements with other countries, Bangladesh can expand the scope of judgments that can be directly enforced under Section 44A of the CPC. Additionally, greater cooperation with international organizations and legal bodies can help Bangladesh align its enforcement practices with global standards.
The enforcement of foreign judgments is an essential component of Bangladesh’s integration into the global economy. As cross-border transactions continue to grow, ensuring that foreign judgments can be reliably enforced in Bangladesh is crucial for fostering international trade and investment. While the current legal framework provides a foundation for enforcement, significant challenges remain that must be addressed through legal reforms, the establishment of specialized courts, and enhanced international cooperation.
For legal practitioners, understanding the intricacies of enforcing foreign judgments in Bangladesh is vital. By staying informed about the legal framework, recognizing the challenges, and advocating for necessary reforms, practitioners can better serve their clients and contribute to the development of a more efficient and effective system for enforcing foreign judgments in Bangladesh.
In conclusion, while the road to enforcing foreign judgments in Bangladesh is fraught with challenges, it is also full of opportunities for improvement. By taking proactive steps to reform the legal framework and enhance international cooperation, Bangladesh can position itself as a reliable jurisdiction for the enforcement of foreign judgments, thereby bolstering its role in the global economy.
Do you require assistance with any services? Contact us for legal assistance.
GLOBAL OFFICES:DHAKA: House 410, ROAD 29, Mohakhali DOHSDUBAI: Rolex Building, L-12 Sheikh Zayed RoadLONDON: 1156, St Giles Avenue, Dagenham
Email Addresses:INFO@TRFIRM.COMINFO@TAHMIDUR.COMINFO@TAHMIDURRAHMAN.COM
24/7 Contact Numbers, Even During Holidays:
+8801708000660+8801847220062
+8801708080817